A creature of habit
Screenfits earns a commission on some links below, at no cost to you. We choose the garments first and find where to buy them second — never the other way round.
A heavy white tee, vintage Levi's, a blue apron, a J.Crew knit and Nike Cortez.
Courtney Wheeler, co-credited with Cristina Spiridakis on season one, settled Carmy on Merz b. Schwanen T-shirts after testing alternatives in the early seasons. Her reasoning: "This is a creature of habit. He obviously pays attention to what he puts on his body, how it's worn, where he got it, what that quality is like" — paired with 1950s Levi's, J.Crew knits and Nike Cortez.
Opaque, boxy, properly cut. Thin cheap tees are why most versions fail.
★ 4.5 · 37 reviews
★ 4.7 · 3,761 reviews
Mid-blue, straight leg, no distressing.
★ 4.2 · 23,572 reviews
★ 4.4 · 602 reviews
Plain canvas, tied at the waist. Genuinely part of the outfit.
★ 4.4 · 542 reviews
Low, plain, retro sole. Nike Cortez was the real choice.
★ 4.2 · 144 reviews
Navy or cream, fine gauge, worn plain.
★ 4.5 · 224 reviews
Unlined, blue or khaki, boxy. Workwear rather than fashion.
★ 4.4 · 10,121 reviews
Brown, narrow, unremarkable.
★ 4.7 · 451 reviews
★ 4.5 · 130 reviews
Small face, fabric or leather strap, no logo.
★ 4.4 · 3,542 reviews
★ 4.2 · 397 reviews
Spend on the T-shirt. That's the entire trick. A heavyweight, opaque, properly cut white tee in a boxy fit — thin, cheap tees are why most people's version of this doesn't work. Jeans should be straight-leg, mid-blue, vintage or vintage-cut. Not slim, not black, not distressed. The apron is genuinely part of the outfit, not a prop. A plain blue or natural canvas apron worn tied at the waist reads as the character instantly. And keep everything else quiet: a navy or cream knit for cold, plain leather trainers, no logos anywhere. This wardrobe is about repetition, so the pieces have to be good enough to repeat.
A heavyweight white tee — thick, snug, holds its collar through a service. Pair with vintage-straight Levi's and the blue apron and you're plated.
Weight and fit. The tee is heavyweight, the jeans break once, nothing is loose. It's a uniform, and uniforms are tailored by repetition.
Thin multipack tees. They collapse by noon — the whole look dies with the collar. Yes, chef.